Skip to main content

Croydon tram crash victims’ families demand new inquest after deaths ruled not unlawful

THE families of Croydon tram crash victims demanded a new inquest into their deaths today after a jury concluded they were not unlawfully killed.

Seven passengers died and a further 51 were injured when the tram derailed in south London on November 9, 2016.

Dane Chinnery, 19, Philip Seary, 57, Dorota Rynkiewicz, 35, Robert Huxley, 63, and Philip Logan, 52, Donald Collett, 62, and Mark Smith, 35, were killed in the crash.

At Croydon Town Hall today, the 10-person inquest jury reached a unanimous conclusion that their deaths were a result of an accident.

Several members of the victims’ families walked out of the room in tears after the decision was announced.

South London senior coroner Sarah Ormond-Walshe refused to call several people who the victims’ families wanted to give evidence about alleged safety failings, it was revealed.

Those potential witnesses include senior managers of operator Tram Operations Ltd (TOL) — a subsidiary of FirstGroup — and Transport for London (TfL), plus other experts and tram drivers.

The victims’ families will now call on the Attorney General Michael Ellis QC to apply to the High Court to grant a new inquest.

They will also seek to judicially review Ms Ormond-Walshe’s decision on which witnesses to call.

Mr Smith’s mother Jean Smith said: “I am bitterly disappointed as justice has not been done today.

“It has been a total farce as we have only heard half of the evidence and no-one who could potentially have been responsible for the crash has been called as a witness.

“It’s morally wrong that we haven’t been able to hear from anybody from TfL, TOL, or the driver during the proceedings, whatever legal precedent says.

“It feels like they have been able to hide from giving evidence and it simply isn’t fair or just. Justice has been suffocated because of the coroner’s ruling.”

The jury concluded that TOL had a risk assessment process which “failed to sufficiently identify the risk” of a tram overturning at the Sandilands curve, did not identify “additional measures to mitigate risk” and had a culture which “discouraged drivers from reporting health and safety concerns.”

First Group chief executive Matthew Gregory insisted that the company has “an unwavering commitment to safety.”

New safety measures introduced with TfL following the crash include improved speed monitoring and restrictions, in-cab safety devices and enhanced roster planning, he said.

During the inquest, the jury heard the tram toppled over and spun off the tracks in darkness and heavy rain near the Sandilands stop after hitting a curve at 73kph (45mph).

The speed limit for that stretch of track was 20kph (12mph).

All of the fatalities had been either fully or partially thrown out of the tram through the windows or doors when the glass shattered.

Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) chief inspector Simon French told the inquest that driver Alfred Dorris may have slipped into a period of “microsleep” on the stretch of track ahead of the curve.

He said extra signage could have mitigated the risk and there were apparent “culture issues” at TOL that meant drivers were unwilling to admit to speeding or other errors.

There was a previous incident just 10 days before the crash when a driver hit the same bend at 45kmh (27mph) and very nearly overturned, but the incident was insufficiently investigated, Mr French added.

Mr Dorris was excused from attending the inquest due to poor health.

The inquest was read evidence that an officer from the Metropolitan Police who was at the scene of the crash heard a man who he believed to be the driver say: “What have I done? I’ve killed them.”

During police interviews, Mr Dorris said that he was “confused,” but when asked if he had fallen asleep he replied: “No, no, no.”

He was arrested at the scene of the crash, but in October 2019 the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) announced that he would not be charged with manslaughter due to a lack of evidence.

The CPS also said the corporate manslaughter charges would not be brought against TfL or TOL.


We're a reader-owned co-operative, which means you can become part of the paper too by buying shares in the People’s Press Printing Society.

Become a supporter

Fighting fund

You've Raised:£ 16,894
We need:£ 1,106
1 Days remaining
Donate today