A TRIBUNAL can order that benefits be awarded to an individual when it finds that deductions are in breach of the Human Rights Act, the Court of Appeal heard yesterday.
Jacqueline Carmichael, who suffers from spina bifida, needs to sleep in a fixed position in a special bed.
She cannot share a bed with her husband and, as there is no space for an additional bed in the room, they require a two-bedroom flat.
But, in November 2012, Sefton Council wrote to the couple to say they had “one more bedroom than your household needs.”
Ms Carmichael’s husband and full-time carer Jayson appealed to the First-tier Tribunal, which ruled in his favour.
In November 2016, the Supreme Court, in a judicial review brought against the bedroom tax by Ms Carmichael, found the government had acted unlawfully against the family in reducing their housing benefit by 14 per cent.
Then, last April, the Upper Tribunal found that applying the deduction would be a “clear breach” of the Carmichaels’ human rights and upheld the First-tier Tribunal’s decision.
The government is appealing against that decision, arguing that the tribunals could not remake decisions in order to eliminate a breach of human rights.
But Richard Drabble QC, for Mr Carmichael, submitted that the upper tribunal’s reasoning was “impeccable” and should be upheld.
He said that a tribunal had the power to decide where the law it was applying would breach the claimant’s human rights.
Mr Drabble added that the size criteria in the bedroom tax rules were made through the “wrong” assumption that a married couple such as the Carmichaels could share a bedroom.
Judgement in the case was reserved and will be delivered at a later date.
You can’t buy a revolution, but you can help the only daily paper in Britain that’s fighting for one by joining the 501 club.
Just £5 a month gives you the opportunity to win one of 17 prizes, from £25 to the £501 jackpot.
By becoming a 501 Club member you are helping the Morning Star cover its printing, distribution and staff costs — help keep our paper thriving by joining!
You can’t buy a revolution, but you can help the only daily paper in Britain that’s fighting for one by become a member of the People’s Printing Press Society.
The Morning Star is a readers’ co-operative, which means you can become an owner of the paper too by buying shares in the society.
Shares are £1 each — though unlike capitalist firms, each shareholder has an equal say. Money from shares contributes directly to keep our paper thriving.
Some union branches have taken out shares of over £500 and individuals over £100.
You can’t buy a revolution, but you can help the only daily paper in Britain that’s fighting for one by donating to the Fighting Fund.
The Morning Star is unique, as a lone socialist voice in a sea of corporate media. We offer a platform for those who would otherwise never be listened to, coverage of stories that would otherwise be buried.
The rich don’t like us, and they don’t advertise with us, so we rely on you, our readers and friends. With a regular donation to our monthly Fighting Fund, we can continue to thumb our noses at the fat cats and tell truth to power.
Donate today and make a regular contribution.