Skip to main content
Film round-up

Secret in Their Eyes (15)
Directed by Billy Ray
3/5
RARELY does a Hollywood remake of an acclaimed film live up to, never mind surpass, the original and this adaptation of the Oscar-winning Argentinian mystery thriller El Secreto de sus Ojos is no exception.

Drawing on a stellar cast, writer-director Billy Ray delivers an adequate crime drama. But it fails to capture the remarkable essence of the original, pandering as it does to those with an aversion to subtitles.

It’s set in Los Angeles, where former FBI investigator Ray Kasten (Chiwetel Ejiofor) returns to the District Attorney’s office with a new lead to convince the DA Claire Sloan (Nicole Kidman), his lost love, to reopen the case of the murder of investigator Jess Cobb’s (Julia Roberts) daughter Caroline 13 years earlier.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
round up
Cinema / 4 December 2025
4 December 2025

LEO BOIX, ANDY HEDGECOCK and MARIA DUARTE review Dreamers, It Was Just An Accident, Folktales, and Eternity

round up
Cinema / 22 August 2025
22 August 2025

ANDY HEDGECOCK and MARIA DUARTE review The Ceremony, Eddington, The Life of Chuck, and The Thursday Murder Club

roundup
Cinema / 17 July 2025
17 July 2025

MARIA DUARTE and ANGUS REID review Friendship, Four Letters of Love, Tin Soldier and The Ballad of Suzanne Cesaire

round up
Cinema / 3 July 2025
3 July 2025

The Star's critics ANGUS REID, MICHAL BONCZA and MARIA DUARTE review Hot Milk, An Ordinary Case, Heads Of State, and Jurassic World Rebirth