Skip to main content
Work with the NEU
A collective crime
GORDON PARSONS welcomes a timely study of the holocaust that indicates the dangers of selectively misremembering it
ODIOUS NAZI HELPERS: At least 3,000 Jews were killed during Lviv pogroms in July 1941, mainly by local Ukrainians [Unknown/Public domain]

The Holocaust: An Unfinished History
Dan Stone, Pelican , £22.00

THE infamous Arbeit Macht Frei welcome emblazoned over the gates of Auschwitz, along with the deadly mushroom cloud carapace over Hiroshima, is arguably one of two formative images conditioning modern consciousness. 

Dan Stone believes we must “move beyond a mechanistic interpretation of industrial genocide” to understand the Holocaust. Rather than a highly efficiently organised and activated transporting, gassing and incinerating of millions of Jews, not to mention Muslim Roma, mentally and physically disabled, homosexuals, trade unionists, communists, Soviet POWs and other “asocials”, almost half of the victims of the Holocaust died of starvation in ghettos or were shot in face-to-face killing actions.

Moreover, while we generally consider the Holocaust to have been first and foremost a German project, without “the almost ubiquitous collaboration across Europe and beyond” the ghastly programme could not have been nearly so extensive. 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Polish victims of a massacre committed by the Ukrainian Insurgent Army in the village of Lipniki, Wołyń (Volhynia), 1943
History / 14 July 2026
14 July 2026

Poland’s anger over Ukraine’s celebration of the Nazi collaborationist UPA reflects more than historical grievance, says KENNY COYLE

Berlin
Books / 5 June 2026
5 June 2026

WILL PODMORE admires an account of the liberation of Berlin that overthrows the conventional US army-inspired account

Shoes at Auschwitz during commemorations in Poland to mark 80 years since the liberation of the concentration camp on 27th January 1945, January 27, 2025
Holocaust Memorial Day 2026 / 27 January 2026
27 January 2026

On May 16 1944, Romani families in Auschwitz-Birkenau armed themselves with stones, tools, and sheer collective will, forcing the SS to retreat – leaving a legacy of defiance that speaks directly to the fascisms of today, says VICTORIA HOLMES

Dr Freud
Theatre review / 16 September 2025
16 September 2025

JAN WOOLF is beguiled by the tempting notion that Freud psychoanalysed Hitler in a comedy that explores the vulnerability of a damaged individual