Skip to main content
Report calls for radical shake-up of Scottish Education

SCOTTISH education should ditch exams for 16-year-olds to help young people succeed, according to a new independent report.

The independent review of qualifications and assessments was commissioned two years ago in the wake of the Scottish Qualifications Authority downgrading the marks of some 125,000 Scottish students, disproportionately hitting working-class learners.

Report author Professor Louise Hayward recommended a “digital profile” for all students to record milestones and plan future learning, and the creation of a new qualification, the Scottish diploma of achievement. 

Teaching union NASUWT’s national official Mike Corbett said that any move to remove or reduce exams will need to carefully consider the potential implications for both students and teachers.

“Teachers have past experience of unwieldy and bureaucratic SQA processes around coursework elements, as indeed does the Cabinet Secretary, and such processes must be avoided in any new system,” he said.

“Placing greater emphasis on personal achievements and extra-curricular activities through a Scottish diploma, while perhaps helping us to move away from a system dominated by high-stakes exams, also has the potential to disadvantage pupils from lower-income backgrounds if not handled carefully and sensitively.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
FIGHTING FOR EDUCATION: Teachers from the Educational Institute of Scotland (EIS) union on the picket line in Glasgow, February 22 2023
TUC Congress 2025 / 6 September 2025
6 September 2025

With 12,000 fewer teachers since 2010 and dwindling resources, Scotland’s schools desperately need investment to support diverse learners rather than empty promises from politicians, writes ANDREA BRADLEY

A child playing with blocks
Scotland / 20 August 2025
20 August 2025
A general view of pupils sitting an exam at Lawrence Sheriff school Rugby, Warwickshire
Education / 5 August 2025
5 August 2025