Skip to main content
Scottish Labour need ‘proper debate’ over its future, says McConnell
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar arrives for First Minister's Questions at the Scottish Parliament in Holyrood, Edinburgh, May 28, 2026

NOW is the time for a “proper debate” over Scottish Labour’s future after its catastrophic results in May’s Holyrood, according to former First Minister Jack McConnell.

Scottish Labour have not gained a seat at a Holyrood general election since the birth of devolution in 1999 when it won 56 seats, and its eight-year term in power — in coalition with the LibDems — ended with Mr McConnell’s defeat at the 2007 election.

Eighteen years on, the SNP is beginning a fifth term in office after Labour slumped to just 17 seats, leading to some Labour figures suggesting separation from the main party should be considered.

But the now Lord McConnell told BBC Radio Scotland: “I like the idea that Burnham is going to run a different kind of Labour Party in terms of debating ideas within the party and outwith the party.”

“Rather than close down that debate, which would have been the case under several leaders in the recent past, I think it’s really important that we can have these debates.

“I think the Scottish Labour Party’s got to have a proper debate, not just about its relationship with the UK party, but about its own policy platform, its ambitions, its internal structure and the campaigning style of the party, what we see the Scottish Parliament as being for.”

“I would strongly urge the leadership of the Scottish party — Douglas Alexander, Anas Sarwar, Jackie Baillie — I would urge them to open this debate up.”

SNP MSP Kate Campbell said: “This is a perennial debate in the Scottish Labour Party and will remain so for as long as they continue to deny the democratic right of the Scottish people to decide our own future.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar at Glasgow International Arena for the 2026 Holyrood elections, May 8, 2026
Voices of Scotland / 21 July 2026
21 July 2026

Scotland's Labour leader cannot continue to evade responsibility for the party's decline, argues LAUREN HARPER

Participants at the Indyref 2020 rally, hosted by the Nation
Scotland / 7 July 2026
7 July 2026
First Minister and SNP leader John Swinney speaking during a press conference at Grassmarket Apex Hotel, Edinburgh, following the 2026 Holyrood elections, May 9, 2026
Features / 11 May 2026
11 May 2026

The new Scottish Parliament looks set to continue a cycle of managerial tinkering while public services face the axe, writes STEPHEN LOW

THE GREAT ILLUSIONIST: Scotland First Minister John Swinney (centre) with assorted worthies at Wheatley Housing Development in Wallyford, East Lothian, apparently keen on accelerating housebuilding throughout Scotland, January 2026
Holyrood / 6 May 2026
6 May 2026

As Scotland heads to the polls, the main parties offer variations on the same script, says MATT KERR