Skip to main content
Lack of clarity on sanctions ‘leads to postcode lottery’

GOVERNMENT rules on benefit sanctions lead to a “postcode lottery” that forces some into poverty, SNP MP Mhairi Black warned yesterday as she tried to tighten up their application.

Moving the second reading of her private member’s Bill in the Commons, the Paisley & Renfrewshire South MP said jobcentre staff’s mood had an effect on whether claimants are sanctioned or not.

Jobcentre staff do a “tremendous job given the system they have to work with” but that everyone has “bad days,” she said, that could end up ruining someone’s ability to be able to pay for food and every day essentials.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Laura van der Hoeven.
Poverty / 24 December 2025
24 December 2025
universal credit
Universal credit / 25 November 2025
25 November 2025

DYLAN MURPHY reports that far from helping people back into work, the sanctions regime is inflicting unnecessary trauma on working-class families

Various For Sale, Sold and Let By estate agent signs juxtaposed next to a Dreams store in Clapham, London
Class / 18 July 2025
18 July 2025

Our housing crisis isn’t an accident – it’s class war, trapping millions in poverty while landlords and billionaires profit. To solve it, we need comprehensive transformation, not mere tokenistic reform, writes BECK ROBERTSON

A Universal Credit sign on a door of a job centre plus in east London
Features / 5 July 2025
5 July 2025

The government’s retreat on PIP still leaves 150,000 new universal credit claimants facing halved benefits from April 2026, creating a discriminatory two-tier welfare system that campaigners must continue fighting, writes DR DYLAN MURPHY