Skip to main content
Running scared of popular poets
TIM WELLS takes issue with a bilious attack on ‘working-class’ artists in a high-end literary magazine
Kate Tempest [Martin Schummann/Creative Commons]

THE JANUARY issue of PN Review contains a hatchet job by Rebecca Watts that has got British poets taking sides.

Nothing unusual there, what is the poetry world without splits and divides? It’s worse than the left. PN Review was described by Simon Armitage as “the political wing of Carcanet Press” and, as much as the hip young poets like social meeja, Professor Plum loves the dagger in the library.

Watts went to both Oxford and Cambridge and those Marks & Spencer ready meals don’t pay for themselves. She takes umbrage at “amateur” poetry, in particular Hollie McNish, Kate Tempest and Rupi Kaur. Hers is basically an attack on “populism,” as she would have it, or access, as many a poet would have it.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
lesbians
Books / 17 July 2026
17 July 2026

DIANE WATT argues that while evidence of sex is not there, a 16th‑century lesbian poet could be Scotland’s answer to Gentleman Jack

kae tempest
Book Review / 7 July 2026
7 July 2026

CAL McBRIDE relishes the lyrical truth of an unstable identity in an over-tidy and conventional social realist treatment

covers
Culture / 2 January 2026
2 January 2026

Two inspring books — that’s your New Year’s musing from me on January 2 2026

cover
Poetry / 26 November 2025
26 November 2025

RUTH AYLETT reviews two collections of outright political poetry