This is the last article you can read this month
You can read more article this month
You can read more articles this month
Sorry your limit is up for this month
Reset on:
Please help support the Morning Star by subscribing here
Government claims that non-residents are costing the NHS as much as £2 billion a year were rubbished yesterday by doctors and opposition leaders.
Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt seized on the headline-grabbing report, released on the same day as the Con-Dem Immigration Bill had its first reading in Parliament, to claim that the NHS could legally be able to claw back at least £500 million of that amount from short-term migrants and foreign visitors who use the service.
The report estimates that so-called "health tourists" - people who travel to Britain specifically to use its health service - could cost as little as £10m.
Ex-pats coming home for free treatment are said to cost the NHS tens of millions a year.
But the report authors repeatedly point out the fragility of their calculations, warning: "The depth and completeness of our analysis has been constrained by the time limitations as well as limitations on the data."
It warns separately in a "note of caution" that its statistics "are based on incomplete data, sometimes of varying quality, and a large number of assumptions."
And British Medical Association GP committee chair Dr Chaand Nagpaul said: "There is limited evidence to suggest that migrants or short-term visitors are consuming large parts of the NHS budget.
"The government's estimates are based on a number of assumptions that result in a figure significantly higher than previous estimates."
Labour shadow health secretary Andy Burnham MP said: "It's hard not to conclude that this announcement is more about spin than substance.
"The government's own report undermines their headline-grabbing figures, admitting they are based on old and incomplete data.
"Labour would not support changes that make doctors and nurses surrogate immigration officials."
A recent European Commission report also concluded that so-called benefits tourism was "neither widespread nor systematic."
Movement Against Xenophobia's Guy Taylor branded yesterday's release a political stunt aimed at strengthening the government's anti-foreigner agenda.
