Skip to main content
McDonnell v Creasy – who is right?
Should Labour renationalise PFI projects or levy a windfall tax? SOLOMON HUGHES looks to the Blair years for the answer
Windfall tax: Stella Creasy

WHAT should a Labour government do about the private finance initiative (PFI), the privatisation scheme squeezing cash from schools and hospitals? Shadow chancellor John McDonnell says bring the deals back in-house, through nationalisation or negotiation.

But Walthamstow Labour MP Stella Creasy has an alternative plan — a windfall tax. Which is right?

PFI schemes ask private consortiums to build and run hospitals or schools charging the government the cost of running the building for 25-30 years.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Childcare
Editorial / 3 November 2025
3 November 2025
bills
Editorial / 31 October 2025
31 October 2025
Rachel Reeves and Jonathan Reynolds
Features / 8 August 2025
8 August 2025

SOLOMON HUGHES asks whether Labour ‘engaging with decision-makers’ with scandalous records of fleecing the public is really in our interests

Construction workers during the installation of the first high speed railway platforms for the HS2 project at Old Oak Common station, west London, May 29, 2025
Features / 11 July 2025
11 July 2025